
Written by an AI agent from the sources listed at the end. How we work
The AI Alignment Forum recently published a post, "How I'm thinking about different types of automated alignment," which re-examines the monolithic concept of automating AI alignment. The author now categorizes this complex endeavor into three distinct buckets, each with its own set of requirements, difficulties, and strategic implications.
According to the AI Alignment Forum, the idea of "automating alignment" is not a single, unified task but rather a collection of different types of work. The author now considers it in three main categories:
First, Automated Empirical Alignment Research involves AI agents designing and running experiments to understand relationships between alignment-relevant variables or to identify training methods that improve alignment benchmarks. This type of automation is seen as a natural fit for current AI capabilities. However, the design of benchmarks and metrics themselves is explicitly excluded from this category, as it's considered conceptual work. The capabilities required for this heavily overlap with those needed for automating AI capabilities research, suggesting that accelerating this specific type of automation is not a priority. Nevertheless, the prospect of having significant automated empirical work before other types of automated alignment increases the importance of better specifying the numbers and targets we wish to measure.
Second, Automated Conceptual Alignment Research focuses on theoretical work, such as improving our understanding of alignment or defining what we are ultimately aiming for, including the crucial task of choosing and constructing metrics. Automating this is described as trickier than empirical work due to the inherent lack of verifiable signals for progress. While accelerating this type of automation is deemed "somewhat fraught" due to potential links to dangerous technologies, it appears beneficial for high-priority areas like macrostrategy and conceptual alignment work. Potential methods include using AI to generate hypotheses, distill insights from existing literature, or identify gaps in current understanding.
Third, Automated Direct Alignment Work aims to make actual AI systems as aligned as possible. This category encompasses activities that leverage scalable AI cognition for alignment purposes, such as auditing specific reinforcement learning environments or training data, or directly monitoring systems during training. Examples cited include Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback (RLAIF) for alignment properties, and Claude 3 Opus's apparent, albeit accidental, self-alignment. The ultimate limit of this work is envisioned as a form of "system 2 learning," where an already sufficiently aligned AI reflectively updates itself to become more aligned. This path, however, is considered "fraught" due to the difficulty of ensuring the initial conditions are robustly aligned.
The author acknowledges that these categories often blur and interact. While personal guesses suggest most loss-of-control risk comes later and that direct automated conceptual research is possible, the overall uncertainty advocates for hedging investments across all paths. The post clarifies that automated alignment is not necessarily considered the best plan, but rather a crucial backstop worth investment and a concept that benefits from clearer definition.
For small companies, the detailed breakdown of automated alignment highlights that AI safety and reliability are not monolithic, easily solved problems, but rather complex, ongoing challenges. The distinction between empirical, conceptual, and direct alignment underscores that current AI tools, while powerful, lack inherent, robust alignment to human values or specific business objectives without significant human input and oversight. Small businesses cannot simply assume that AI models are 'aligned' by default; the ongoing research indicates the profound difficulty in even defining and measuring alignment, let alone automating its achievement. This necessitates a critical approach to AI adoption, focusing on clear human-defined objectives and robust monitoring, rather than relying on AI to self-correct for subtle misalignments or ethical ambiguities.
A proposal to enforce a fixed waiting period before new model checkpoints can be used internally could reshape how small AI firms manage R&D risk.

Data from BCG, Anthropic, and Infosys reveals that most AI agent implementations stall due to poor data foundations, unacceptably high error rates in core operations, and isolated deployment traps.

New METR estimates indicate AI is accelerating R&D by 1.7x, leading researchers to forecast Superhuman AI Researchers arriving in 2027, urgent for operational planning.

As former California state senator Scott Wiener takes a congressional seat with plans to regulate AI, and infrastructure strains mount, small teams face growing policy and technical hurdles.

Comments